There are substantial variations between regions of
the world in the incidence of all childhood cancers combined
and of the principal diagnostic groups [
9]. In affluent
countries, the most common childhood cancer types
are leukemias, followed by CNS tumors and lymphomas
[
9]. In our series, the distribution of childhood cancer was
similar with this pattern: most common childhood malignant
diseases were leukemias (26%), CNS tumors (21%)
and malignant lymphomas (14%). Hodgkin’s lymphoma
constituted 6.85% of all malignant diseases and 48% of
lymphomas enrolled in our institution.
The incidence rates for 1073 children with lymphoma
and solid tumors registered to the Turkish Pediatric Oncology
Group (TPOG) Pediatric Tumor Registry 2002 revealed
that lymphomas (26.8%) were the most common
pediatric malignant disorder excluding leukemias, followed
by CNS tumors (21.1%) [10]. The data including
childhood leukemias was only available after the collaboration
of the Turkish Pediatric Oncology Group (TPOG)
and Turkish Pediatric Hematology Associations in 2005.
The national data from these two associations showed the
distribution of the most common cancer types in 1435
children as follows; leukemia 27.2%, lymphomas & reticuloendothelial
system (RES) 16.7% (Hodgkin’s lymphoma
9.9%), CNS/intracranial/intraspinal 11.6% [11].
These results were consistent with a developing country
pattern. The incidence of lymphoma tends to be higher in the Middle East Cancer Consortium (MECC) countries
than in Europe [12]. However, our own data showed
similar figures with the developed countries [9]. Although
we didn’t have an analysis on socio-economic status of
this patient population, this striking difference can be explained
with different socio-economic and cultural profile
of our patients or may be due to some genetic differences.
In accordance with our incidence rates, the results from
the Ýzmir Cancer Registry shows that the childhood cancer
patterns in Ýzmir region mostly resembles the western
population’s figures; leukemias (30.6%) followed by CNS
tumors (21.3%), and lymphomas (15%) were the most
common malignant diseases in Ýzmir [7]. In our region,
besides the ranking of tumors, the total and site specific
incidence rates are very close to the developed countries
[12,13].
The median age of our patients was 10 years. The most
recent data on pediatric HL in Turkey showed a median
age lower (8 y) than in developed countries [6]. Previously
published data from the other regions of Turkey were
also consistent with this result (Table 4). We had only
four patients (10%) younger than 5 years of age during
the initial diagnosis. In other series from Turkey, this ratio
was higher: 29.7% was ≤ 5 years of age; 17.6% was <5
years of age and 32.3% was <7 years of age, respectively
[3-5]. Reports from other developing countries show that
pediatric HL occurs at a younger age with as many as 15
to 30% of cases occurring before 5 years of age, against
some 5% in developed countries [1,8,14-17]
Table 4: Epidemiologic and histopathologic data from some Turkish pediatric HL series
In this study group, M:F ratio was 1.7:1. The other series
reported a higher M:F ratio up to 5.3 (Table 4). Pediatric
HL presents a slight male predominance in Western
countries with an M:F ratio close to 1.5:1. However, there
is a large male excess in less economically developed
countries, with an M:F ratio between 2.5:1 and 5:1 [1].
In contrast to the general national figures as well as the
data from other developing countries, which all showed a
MC predominant histopathologic subtype, the predominance
of NS (NS) histology (55%) was the most prominent
feature of our study population. However, 31% of
our cases had MC histology, a proportion higher than the
incidence observed at the developed countries [9,18,19].
Distribution of HL cases over age, gender, geographical
areas and socio-economic settings have long suggested
multiple etiologically distinct entities for HL, rather
than a single disease. The prevalent type in developing countries is the MC histological subtype, predominates
in young children, particularly in males, mostly presents
as advanced stage disease. These features could be partly
explained by the hypothesis of an etiologic role of EBV
in the pathogenesis of HL. Studies have shown a causal
relationship between infectious mononucleosis and subsequent
Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)-positive HL [20-25].
Çavdar et al. [3] showed the high frequency of EBV-related
LMP-1 positivity (73.6%) in pediatric HL cases.
Childhood Hodgkin’s lymphoma in developed countries
affects mainly older children, mostly presenting as NS
histological subtype and might be explained with a delayed
exposure to common infectious agents as there is an
increased male susceptibility to viral and bacterial infection
in childhood, which is more marked in the first five
years of life [1,18].
Most of the data coming from the other centers, as
well as the TPOG data including 1823 children from 22
different centers from all over the country is consistent
with a developing country pattern of HL (type I) characterized
by a high incidence of MC histological subtype, a
younger median age and a male predominance (Table 4).
Our data, reflecting the figures from the extreme west part
of our country was more consistent with the data from
affluent countries [18,26-29]. The higher socio-economic
and cultural status of this geographical area may be a contributing
factor for this striking difference.
Nine patients had (23%) treatment failures in our
study, one of them being resistant disease (Table 3). This
patient with Stage IVsB HL with extensive pulmonary
metastasis during the initial presentation developed resistant
disease after 6 courses of COPP. She received three
courses of ABED (Adriamycin, Bleomycin, Etoposide,
Dacarbazine) and mediastinal radiotherapy, followed by
BEAM protocol (Carmustin, Etoposide, Ara-C, Melphalan)
and autologous stem cell transplantation. She reached
complete remission but developed therapy related AML at
39th month of ABMT and died with progressive disease.
Five of these relapse cases had NS histology. They
all initially achieved complete remission but relapsed at
a median of 18 months. Four relapses occurred at the primary
site (two in the irradiated, two in the unirradiated
site), two occurred at both the primary and out-of-primary
sites and only one occurred at out of the primary site (Table 3). All relapsed patients, except one with stage IVSB
HL, were initially irradiated with doses between 1980 to
3960 cGy to the primary site. It should be noted that these
doses were adequate for controlling disease.
The 5-year EFS was 77% and OS was 96% in this
patient group. The 10-year EFS and OS rates were 73%
and 92%, respectively. Even though it was not statistically
significant, EFS and OS rates in advanced disease were
lower than in the early stage disease. These survival rates
are comparable with some other series from Turkey [4-6]. Although no significance could be shown, The EFS in
patients receiving GPOH 90 protocol was lower (5 and
10 year EFS was 55%) than the patients who received
COPP/ABVD based regimens (5 and 10 year OS were
100% and 83% respectively). Our results with GPOH-HD
90 protocol were less satisfactory as compared with those
reported by DAL/GPOH-HD study groups of OS and EFS
98% and 91% for all stages [8]. Inferior survival rates,
compared with the results of the GPOH-HD group, has
been reported in Iranian children who also received German-
Austrian DAL-HD 85-90 protocol (5 and 16 year OS
94.4% and 88.1%, EFS 79.2% and 75.4%, respectively)
[30]. Although the number of patients was not enough to
draw a conclusion, one should consider some other poor
prognostic factors which could not be shown with this patient
size, such as the high number of patients with bulky
disease (66%.) There might also be some undetermined
histological risk factors such as subtypes of NS histology
(NS1 vs. NS2). A recent large scale study from the DALHD-
90 group showed that NS2 histology had a major
negative impact on treatment outcome in HL [29]. Another
pediatric study from Turkey showed that NS histologic
subtype resulted in a significant decrease (p=0.02) in EFS
(49.2 months for NS and 72.2 months for the other subtypes),
however they did not have any subclassification
of NS subtype since it had not been a common practice in
pediatric HL [5]. At another center in Turkey, treatment
protocol had been tailored according to the histological
subtype, long before the industrialized countries have
started to search for risk-based treatment regimens: they
used to give ABVD+IFRT (involved field RT) for stage
I-II patients with NS and lymphocyte depletion subtypes,
where other stage I-II patients were given COPP+ IFRT
between June1984 and December 1992 [4].
Beside histological subtypes, many other factors could
be contributing on the outcome of HL patients. Saunders et
al. [19] showed that EFS rate of patients with unfavorable
disease was lower in underprivileged countries as compared
to that at the industrialized countries, even when
the same therapy regimen was used. Each population has
its own characteristics, so any therapy regimen resulting in an excellent outcome under given conditions does not
necessarily lead to the same outcome under different conditions.
Considerable differences have been shown in the
distribution of histological types as well as the survival
rates of pediatric HL among the regions of Europe [18].
These variables may also be differing within the different
geographic regions of a large country.
The outcome of children with HL has greatly improved
with 5-year overall survival rates greater than 95%, and 5-
year EFS greater than 90% for all stages for the last two
decades [1-5]. Treatment results have shown considerable
improvement even in developing countries. The main challenge today is finding a balance between maximizing cure
and minimizing the late effects [31]. Therefore, emphasis
is now on tailoring therapy according to the risk groups
which should be based on well-defined prognostic factors.
Several study groups from the developed countries have
been searching for the efficacy of risk-based therapies using
risk factors determined in their own populations [27-29,32-34]. Since epidemiologic and clinicopathologic
features of HL show considerable variations even within
our country, we need to define our own prognostic factors.
This major objective could only be achieved with multicentric
national clinical trials.